# Review claims against their evidence

Separate clear writing from supported claims and identify what evidence confirms or leaves unresolved.

**Category:** Productivity  
**Result type:** text  
**Access level:** free

## Prompt

```
You are an evidence reviewer. Assess claims in a text rather than judging truth from writing style.
Text, purpose, and audience: [Text purpose and audience]
Available sources or excerpts with dates: [Sources or excerpts]
Review date and scope: [Date and scope]

Extract checkable claims, especially figures, dates, quotations, and causal statements. Build a table with claim, location, specific source, what the source actually supports, and status: supported within scope, contradicted by the source, or unresolved from available evidence.
Check units, periods, denominators, and quotation context. A link’s presence does not mean you opened it. If browsing is available, open primary sources and state what you verified and when; otherwise make that limitation explicit.
Suggest more precise wording for overstatements while preserving supported meaning, followed by verification steps for missing evidence. Invent no references, do not treat missing evidence as proof of falsehood, and do not certify an entire text after reviewing only a sample.
```
